Hotéis em Cidade Antiga, Edimburgo

Prós: Location, price and affordability, cool design, friendly staff, open lounge/bar/restaurant with good hours. Quiet rooms!

Contras: AWFUL WiFi- we resorted to paying roaming charges on our mobile phone b/c we needed to get online. No phone in room to call to lobby? Very little lounging furniture-even an extra armchair or loveseat would be nice. Name 'Motel One' cud be better:)

Prós: location

Contras: no double double rooms

Prós: Great location. Nice lobby. Clean. Price not bad comparatively.

Contras: Spartan rooms that could easily be improved upon, ie. luggage racks, any decoration, lighting inside room entrance, TV system that works. One desk person (seemed like manager) said we had good view room - view was of us for double buses parked in front.

Prós: Location, early check in, fab breakfast, good drinks and dinner....

Contras: Can't think of anything

Prós: Great location, superb interior design of the room. Very modern style

Contras: In-hotel gym was temporarely out of service bu the hotel offered a free entry at a partner gym

Prós: Spacious suite living room, separate half guest bath, Decent breakfast with separate order menu, gym had free weights to 30kg, location is on royal mile down road from castle (but for Christmas markets and shopping, a princess street hotel would been better), overall friendly staff.

Contras: 1. For a royal mile suite, main bathroom was standard. Overly spacious living room really could’ve spared space for a more comfortable bathroom befitting suite. 2. Website advertised kids eat free. However, when we ordered meals for the kids via room service, we were told it’s not free. Extremely deceptive and off putting of brand. 3. I emailed the hotel 1 week in advance of 4-day stay and asked for milk, orange juice, and water in room stocked and included room mini fridge. Email from customer service acknowledged request and even confirmed we still wanted wine and beer - a nice catch! However, when we arrived, we were informed juice and milk not included. False service promise should’ve not been made. Room service food was Not worth price (pizza, burger, and kids chicken meal were only ok but far more expensive than eaterery options all around).

Prós: Breakfast was amazing! Staff were very helpful and hospitality was good

Contras: The fridges were dirty and the carpets could do with new ones

Prós: Old world charm meets modern amenities- you can't go wrong with this hotel right on the royal mike in Edinburgh. Excellent staff, well maintained rooms, and full service. Health club has good assortment of machines and free weights.

Contras: It's bloody cloudy in Scotland- spent an entire week and didn't see the sun once.

Prós: the proximity to the main Edinburgh attractions, parking availability, supply of extra pillows, big rooms.

Prós: good facility. hospitallity of staffs. and location.

Contras: somehow internet is not working properly good in both case of WIFI nor Wired connection.

Prós: Easy to drive to and park my car. Ideal city centre location. Exclusive hotel for a rugby supporter's weekend.

Prós: Room was very comfortable. There was lots of choice for breakfast. The hotel location was very good for castle and other attractions. We were near lots of restaurants.

Prós: The upgraded room was appreciated we will stay here again.

Contras: Did not have breakfast - thought that £16.50 was expensive

Prós: Good car parking. Close to city center. Great breakfast. Frendley staff

Prós: Location

Prós: Large, confortable rooms. Located within walking distance to all city attractions

Contras: Noice from neighbouring pubs at night/early morning.

Prós: Central location, valet parking

Prós: Efficient, slightly impersonal, no problems

Contras: I resent the fact that they doubled the prices of their rooms during the Edinburgh Festival. I also think for the price breakfast should be included.

Prós: Hotel is better than i expect, warmer, clener, and quiet

Contras: Breakfast is quit expensive, compering what you get.

Prós: We love the beds and the huge wide screen TV!

Contras: It was a little far from Waverley station, had to climb up and down a hill to get to the hotel!

Prós: The location of the hotel is fantastic. Everything one needs to see in Edinburgh is within walking distance. Our room was spacious and towards the back of the building, so there was no noise coming from Grassmarket at all although we stayed there for the weekend.

Prós: Very central to Edinburgh, very nice pubs nearby and easy walk to all of the tourist sections of the town. Very helpful staff and very nice breakfast.

Prós: The hotel was modernly decorated and the rooms were of excellent quality and the food was of constant high standard

Prós: They had parking, toiletries were good

Contras: the fridge was only a cooler and it would have been nice to have a proper cold fridge. Breakfast quite expensive.

Prós: Friendly staff. Very well appointed rooms

Prós: Helpful staff Modern decor and beautiful view of the castle

Contras: Noisy guests sitting in the lounge area on 4th floor just outside our bedroom.

Prós: Good locatioin, friendly staff, breakfast excellent, room comfortable

Contras: Very small car park

Prós: Helpful staff, clean rooms, good location

Contras: Carpet was filthy upon check in trash from previous guest was still there. Hair in shower stall dirty sock under bed. Room was extremely hot and unable to sleep from bar noise screaming at 4 am. Room was extremely overpriced as I would rate this hotel one star. I would never stay at another Ibis

Prós: It is centrally located so we found it very convenient for a short weekend trip.

Contras: The room was small. We would prefer indoor slippers within the room but otherwise, the hotel was clean and served its purpose well for a weekend trip to Edinburgh.

Prós: The hotel was perfetly located and very clean, management was competent and friendly.

Contras: The price was on the higher side, I dd not even find a complimentar water in my room. This was less than expected.

Prós: Perfect location and good value for money

Contras: Bed - not the most confortable one...

Prós: Great location, clean rooms, excellent shower, friendly staff...good value for money.

Contras: No real negatives for the price.

Prós: Excellent central location particularly for places of interest. Large room with comfy bed. Staff pleasant and helpful.

Contras: Bathrooms very compact

Prós: Nice quiet hotel with friendly staff.

Contras: None

Prós: Pleasant, helpful staff. Nice room, clean.

Contras: Some guests were a bit noisy, running through the corridors whilst drunk.

Prós: Size of room; check-out time; reaction to things needing attention; friendly staff; comfortable bed; great location

Contras: Bathroom a bit small, cramped and no ventilation; couldn't open/shut the window without getting someone to unlock; in spite of filling in a form on arrival, the room wasn't registered in my name, so when my taxi came they couldn't get in touch with me and sent it away! (But they got me another one almost immediately). Bar too small and too visible to be relaxing.

Prós: Very comfortable; excellent sound-proofing of room with air conditioning to keep it cool

Contras: Front desk staff seemed a bit overworked (but very busy time of year)

Prós: The hotel is modern with comfortable rooms. There is a good provision of a variety of meals and snacks 24hrs, even breakfast facilities before 5.30am. Location is a short walk to the Airport Bus.

Contras: Too much noise throughout the night from people making their way home from clubs etc

Prós: The location is perfect, and especially impressive for the price. The staff left a little to be desired - the service was a bit perfunctory.

Prós: The high standard of design, the cleanliness and the location make the Aparthotel ideal for stays in Edinburgh

Prós: Really enjoyed our stay here this week. We even got upgraded to an executive suite which we hadn't asked for which was a bonus :)

Prós: Very convenient with children having their own bedroom. Having a kitchen made it easier for children on restricted diet. Secure parking very useful. 24 hour reception is excellent. Great location but still nice and quiet.

Contras: Car parking spaces were very small and difficult to get in and out of. The cleaner left some toxic cleaning material in the bathroom by accident.

Prós: Very good location, excellent value for money - wanted 2 bedrooms, apartment cost £90/night for 2 of us. Could not have got that rate anywhere in a hotel in Central Edinburgh at that standard. kitchen very useful and well equipped - living room comfortable. nice to have 2 bathrooms.

Prós: Roomy and comfortable. Well equipped. Good location

Contras: some building work and parking was tight

Prós: location/ free use of the lobby coomputer/ the staff are very helpful and very nice. I felt very safe and secure.

Contras: I would have prefered a more quite room, not located near the busy road. I think the beds could be a bit more comfortable.

Prós: conveniently situated

Prós: Very stylish and up to date; very central;

Contras: Nothing

Prós: Having separate lounge and kitchen

Prós: great room,good location

Prós: It was great ! The people was helpful !

Prós: Spacious rooms and vaulted ceilings. Extremely comfortable beds and wonderful views of the city.

Contras: Sloppy paint job in the room. The shower drain was clogged and the shower floor was very slick and dangerous. Easy fixes though to bring the room up to speed.

Prós: The friendly and welcoming attitude of the staff, in particular the concierge. The have maintained the standard of the hotel since changing to a Hilton. It was well located for walking to Murrayfield for rugby.

Prós: Service and attention to detail

Contras: Nothing to report

Prós: excellent staff shame about the hotel.

Contras: qeues for brakefast,electrcity cutting out in the room due to faulty wiring. not a five star as far as i could see gets the rating on facilitys rather than class,

Prós: nothing

Contras: It is a very old Hotel .It needs to be renovated urgently .The toilet flush is broken , noisy AC , non hot water avaliablility ( it was for a limited time but not expected from a five star Hotel ) . The staff talk without looking at your face with an unfriendly manner . The pool is again too old and need to be renewed so that the price paid to the Hotel is too much in comparison what you get .

Prós: Good reception we arrived early room ready and all very efficient similarly check out very efficient

Contras: Breakfast, we were put in a cold room, toast took an age to produce , one poor machine and when we left the queue was 25 yards long to get in for breakfast

Prós: Absolutely everything. I had always wanted to stay at the hotel and t lived up to all of my expectations

Contras: The only thing I would change would have been to have a bigger bed in our room. Kingsize just wasn't big enough!!

Prós: Delightful! We hope to return to Edinburgh one day, and when we do, we will stay at the Caledonian.

Contras: Couldja make it stop raining?

Prós: Everything was great except bed was very uncomfortable

Prós: The room was quiet and had a lovely view of Edinburgh. The staff were very helpful and the standard of cleanliness excellent. The leisure facilities were of a high standard also.

Contras: The price of breakfast seemed high even for the standard of hotel.

Contras: It was in reform so the outdoor appearance was not nice. I would have liked that in the website they had mentioned it.

Prós: Great staff! Very attentive and helpful and so friendly! The facilities are clean and comfortable. It's about a 15 min walk to the castle and the royal mile.

Prós: Good position close to city centre and university

Prós: The location is very good and the staff were friendly and attentive. These were the redeeming features.

Contras: Poor car parking facilities, breakfast was uninspiring, room was not particularly clean.

Prós: Excellent breakfast!

Contras: Limited parking available

Prós: Room was very spacious, clean and overall good value for money. Location good also

Prós: quality of room and first meal

Contras: I thought the price of the breakfast was excessive at £19 for a hot breakfast.Went next door to Premier and got all you can east breakfast for £7.95. Also got breakfast in cafe just down the road for £4.95. This would put be off coming back. Maybe go to premier inn next door.

Prós: Nice staff

Contras: Did not get a separate bed for child (2years old) Poor kids playcorner

Prós: room service and cleanliness of room both excellent

Contras: Decor could be modernised a bit. No sink in the toilet for washing hands

Prós: Very nice room. Good sized bathroom. Excellent breakfast. As compared to most other hotels, the hot breakfast is part of the standard buffet.

Contras: The dinner experience was not great. We tried Italian, Indian and Thai cuisine. Only the Thai cuisine was good.

Prós: Breakfast was good, whirlpool was good.

Contras: Air con was not great and swimming pool is very small

Prós: the staff brilliant with the children and nothing was to much trouble for them