Hotéis em Cidade Antiga, Edimburgo

Prós: The room was very well-appointed with great finishes and amenities.

Contras: Location wasn't as close to everything as we'd have liked, but it was walkable.

Prós: Nice location, nice character about this hotel

Contras: Nothing

Prós: Great breakfast selection. Comfortable room with thoughtful touches

Contras: Would have liked a bath

Contras: Everything about the hotel fabulous we will return again without a doubt.

Prós: Breakfast was great. Room was big and very clean. Nice modern facilities. Staff was very helpful and pleasing to deal with. Location was quiet and convienent.

Contras: It was all very nice.

Prós: I had stayed in the skyline junior suite which has a nice view. It was spacious and reasonably clean. The staff are friendly and the location is very good.

Contras: The bed was not comfortable

Prós: Loved the quiet location; no traffic noise yet in the middle of the city. Also I left something in my room and the staff on reception were wonderful at finding it and reuniting me with it later in the day.

Prós: Wonderful location 5 minutes from the Royal Mile. Beautiful clean and sparkling room. Fantastic value for money. We stayed overnight before going off on a coach trip round the highlands but it would be great to use as a base for visiting Edinburgh for a few days.

Contras: Absolutely nothing.

Prós: Breakfast very good all food very good staff very good would recommend this hotel we had a great time.

Contras: Northing

Prós: The staff were exemplary. The food was not overpriced it was good value for money and of an excellent standard.

Contras: Nothing.

Prós: Every thing!

Contras: Nothing!

Prós: Decor was fab Bathroom excellent Very clean

Contras: Couldn’t work out how to turn off the light behind TV so had to sleep with it on!

Prós: The staff, location and facilities are good. Bar functional but nothing special.

Contras: Room 623 was small for the price - the Air con didn't work properly and during our first night a sensor in the air con unit triggered an alarm that woke us up. Futhermore the room is next to a storage cupboard that was accessed quite frequently from around 7am and at several times in the day and evening, each time the user slammed the door in and out! What should have been a restful holiday was ruined for us because of this. Hotel staff friendly and helpful but this did not make up for the frequent, noisey disturbances.

Prós: The bed was super soft. Location on the Royal Mile was great for shopping for woollen goods. Some of the staff went out of their way to be extremely helpful when there was a rally outside and I couldn't get a taxi.

Contras: The initial staff member at Checkin was very abrupt to the point of rudeness and kept me waiting and waiting, but the next Checkin lass was very pleasant. The buffet breakfast was very ordinary for the price of the hotel - I had much better in 3 star hotels.

Prós: Great Staff, great location. Can't fault the hotel at all

Contras: Loved everything about it.

Prós: Great location on the Royal Mile. Good breakfast. Great hotel.

Prós: Good breakfast

Contras: Dark rooms and small windows

Prós: Location, early check in, fab breakfast, good drinks and dinner....

Contras: Can't think of anything

Prós: Very comfy bed, clean room, friendly staff

Prós: Everyone and everything was amazing thank you so much

Contras: Nothing could have been better

Prós: Spacious room with a big, comfy bed and a small seating area. Very clean, good breakfast selection and friendly, efficient staff. Central location on the Royal Mile but our room was very quiet even with the window open. TV options were good once we had got the internet connection sorted.

Contras: The hospitality tray could have been better and I don’t like having to ask for a mini-bar.

Prós: Location

Contras: Shower

Prós: Spacious suite living room, separate half guest bath, Decent breakfast with separate order menu, gym had free weights to 30kg, location is on royal mile down road from castle (but for Christmas markets and shopping, a princess street hotel would been better), overall friendly staff.

Contras: 1. For a royal mile suite, main bathroom was standard. Overly spacious living room really could’ve spared space for a more comfortable bathroom befitting suite. 2. Website advertised kids eat free. However, when we ordered meals for the kids via room service, we were told it’s not free. Extremely deceptive and off putting of brand. 3. I emailed the hotel 1 week in advance of 4-day stay and asked for milk, orange juice, and water in room stocked and included room mini fridge. Email from customer service acknowledged request and even confirmed we still wanted wine and beer - a nice catch! However, when we arrived, we were informed juice and milk not included. False service promise should’ve not been made. Room service food was Not worth price (pizza, burger, and kids chicken meal were only ok but far more expensive than eaterery options all around).

Prós: Staff were very helpful, great location

Contras: Nothing

Prós: Everything was great! Great location and nice room. Staff was friendly and helpful.

Prós: We were upgraded on check-in to a spacious corner suite with a beautiful view of Calton Hill and a bit of Holyrood Park. We appreciating having a bit of room to spread out, and the unit was clean and comfortable. Good location on Canongate, convenient to everything in Old Town (as well as to Waverley Station) but just that little bit away from the mobs further up the Royal Mile.

Contras: The price was reasonable for Edinburgh ... but still by far the most expensive of anywhere we stayed during two weeks in Scotland. The plaza below our room seemed a favourite with local skateboarders ...

Prós: Fantastic location right on the Royal Mile near Holyrood and within walking distance of Edinburgh Castle.

Prós: good location.

Prós: The room was spacious enough for me to occupy one (a sofa bed) and another for my parents. There were doors and you could use them to separate the rooms into two; privacy could be guaranteed. Location was also amazing, it’s on the lower end of the Royal Mile, and the Edinburgh Castle is just approx. 15-20 minute walk away, but it’s going to be walking up the hill so it might need some efforts. On the other hand the Holyrood Palace’s just below the hotel so walk down for 5-10 minutes you’ll see the palace there. Plenty of restaurants nearby as well. A good value choice if you look forward to staying in the center of the Old Town.

Prós: 1.Loaction. 2.We can cooking by ourselves.

Contras: Receptionist are not familiar with mobile setting when we facing disconnection of wi-fi.

Prós: Location was amazing. Bed was super comfy and it was bigger than I thought it would be. Great shower!

Contras: Not as clean as I would have liked. Staff were a little slow moving.

Prós: Location on the Royal Mile was great. You could have windows open in room and still have a quiet nights sleep on a Friday and Saturday night. Beds were comfortable and accommodation & kitchenette facilities were clean.

Contras: Checked in around 7-8pm with two tired children the first attendant was helpful, however after making the Children’s sofa bed and noticing there was one sheet short I went downstairs and asked staff on reception for a sheet. I was advised by someone different that all linen was available in the room, and that I had some how missed seeing it. I did let her know that both my husband and I both had checked all the cupboards and drawers and it definitely was not in the room and if I could please get one. She was quite persistent that the sheet was in the room and that I had missed it, however she would come up to the room to check. 10mins later she arrives at our room and asked what we are missing, didn’t show us where to look at all after all of that and go gets the sheet. Not a great first impression, I must say. I also would suggest not to have the lobby, entrance and outside lift floors mopped or still wet at 8-9am when most traffic is moving through due to your guests slipping, even if you do place a load of signs “wet floors” around the place. Found the price to be quite expensive considering No breakfast is included and you still pay for parking on top. Staff could be more attentive to guests needs with a willingness to help.

Prós: The position is superb! It’s on the Royal Mile giving very easy access to all of Edinburgh. A particularly nice gesture was tea/coffee/ice cream as a welcome/allow to relax feature on offer at the end of the afternoon - thank you.

Contras: Very little I didn’t like apart from the cost of breakfast which was £13.00 per person. Would have appreciated a tea/coffee option with toast/croissant only and at a reduced price - that is, less than £13.00 per person.

Prós: Great location, very clean

Prós: Everyone was great especially front desk staff

Prós: Localização excelente, tamanho do quarto bom, atendentes da recepção delicados. Internet boa

Contras: Banheiro inapropriado, com pia muito baixa e banheira muito alta, escorregadia e sem nenhum suporte para apoio. Ficamos 3 noites e nunca foi trocado os lençóis, apesar de sujos. O homem que fazia a limpeza do quarto um dia entrou no nosso quarto as 8:20h am. Um dia não deixou tapete de banheiro. Já os garçons do bar ficavam conversando e sequer olhavam para os convivas. Tínhamos que ir ao bar solicitar que nos atendessem. Na hora de pagar ocorria o mesmo

Prós: The Hotel is located in a great spot! Close to restaurants and lots of main attractions, hop on hop off bus stop right in front of hotel. The staff was very pleasant and customer service was good.

Contras: It is a little outdated, they are in the works of renovation. clean bed, shower and bathrooms need a deep thorough cleaning not just wiping down BUT scrubbing with disinfectants.

Prós: Fabulous breakfast enjoyed being able to view people and location

Prós: Great location and friendly staff. Secure parking was a bonus!

Prós: Location , swimming pool ,food .

Contras: Noise early morning around 6am

Contras: Hand basin in the bathroom was too low with me being 6ft 2 it was only knee height and the bath was very high to step into

Contras: I am disabled & was unable to access the public toilets from the bar / dining area.

Prós: Fantastic view, friendly helpful staff, excellent location, modern clean hotel that is perfectly located in the heart of Edinburgh!

Prós: Staff are extremely friendly and helpful, the hotel was ideally situated, and the view from our room was brilliant bedroom was very nice and bed was very comfortable. We had breakfast on the last day and it was delicious lots of choice.

Prós: the breakfast was a disgrace and the supervisor was abrupt and rude

Contras: get what is ordered

Prós: The rooms are not air conditioned, rather surprising for a 4 star hotel. When I enquirer about a slightly later check out the reception informed that a £10 charge per hour after 11 am official check out time would be levied. This hugely incentivizes us to try our level best not to return to this hotel, location notwithstanding

Contras: As above

Prós: Amazing view of the Edinburgh Castle and the location couldnt be better. The staff were mostly friendly and arranged a taxi for us when we needed it. The hotel is very clean and the beds were very comfortable. Would definitely go back. Every hotel is overpriced theses days in my opinion so I can't complain about their prices because they are as overpriced as everywhere else.

Contras: The only complaints were there was no water coolers or places to fill up water other than the fitness room. The fitness room is available and I'm glad they had it but it is very small and if there are two people it is crowded, but still, it is nice they have anything.

Prós: Great rooms, great view from the room

Contras: Too steep to get on foot from the train station

Prós: Superb service from all hotel staff

Contras: The rooms were noisy.. I could hear people opening and closing (loudly) their doors and talking. Shame! I used eat plugs to sleep.

Prós: Location

Contras: Our room, 416, being big, hasn’t got enough light, because the window is narrow and there aren’t enough lamps. This room is long, like a corridor, and the tv is very far from the beds. The furniture isn’t practical at all and the color scheme isn’t very suitable! Overall this room is not very comfortable! The continental breakfast hasn’t got enough variety!

Prós: Location was great and so was the breakfast!

Prós: The location was fine

Contras: The awful room we were placed in. It is a handicapped room. We asked immediately to change and the answer was “somebody has to stay in it”unfortunately we were there for 5 nights and the room was horrid. The sink is so low you have to be on your knees to wash your face, the counter do not accommodate toiletries, no bath mat, no make up mirror, no chair to relax in. No place in shower to place shampoo. Worst hotel for almost $300 a night we have stayed in

Prós: Hotel is in a great location, the staff is great and the property is very well maintained. And the jars of candy at the reception area were a nice daily bonus! Our room had a great view of the city. The bar is fun on weekends.

Contras: Rooms have almost no drawer or shelf space. There is adequate hanging room, but plan to live out of your suitcase.

Prós: Location was very good. It was only a short walk to Edinburgh Castle and in the vicinity of many restaurants and cafes.

Contras: The hotel is built on a irregularly shaped block. The room to which we were allocated had only one small window overlooking rear of the premise and facing a wall of another structure. The view was unsightly and ugly. The hotel is small however, one of the two lifts was not working. This created unnecessarily long waits which are entirely avoidable. The appointment of the hotel is modern however, its minimalism does not make it feel like a 5 star hotel.

Prós: Ótimas acomodações. Cama confortável, banheiro grande, chuveiro com boa pressão de água. Staff simpático e solícito.

Contras: Os serviços extras são um pouco caros para nós brasileiros.

Prós: Beautiful hotel and location. Staff were very friendly and helpful

Contras: Nothing

Prós: Comfortable stylish room with modern decor. Great shower staff friendly and helpful

Contras: Bedside tables too low. Breakfast expensive not much seating space in foyer

Contras: Breakfast was a disappointment. Poor selection and to long waiting time