Sanctuary Hotel New York

Small rooms but overall great

Prós: fantastic service, great staff, good location

Contras: smallish rooms, lack of closet space

Prós: The staff at the front desk and the doormen are so helpful!!

Prós: Staff was wonderful, interior was beautiful, rooms where very comfortable, entire experience made for quite a romantic stay.

Contras: Rooftop bar wasn't as great as I'd hoped. The design was trendy, but the clientele was decidedly not. Fortunately, the hotel is in a great area with plenty else to do nearby.

Prós: Great location, 1/2 block from Times Square TKTS, and walking distance from Grand Central. Classy hotel, lobby and room furnishings, it was great for a long weekend for the two of us.

Contras: After Kayak gave us an opportunity to request a superior view, we got a 9th floor room. In that room space around the bed was small, as was closet space also, and only one chair.

Very close to Times Square

Prós: The room was very nice and clean. The location was excellent. The rooftop bar was really cool too. The staff was extremely friendly.

Contras: I guess if I had to complain about anything it would just be the size of the room, it was very small. But I know that it is typical for many NYC hotels.

Prós: Great front desk, bellman and concierge staff. Nice breakfast.

Contras: Room wasn't ready per check in time.